Why Plant-Based Meat Fails to Impress the Chinese: Insights from a Chinese Vegetarian

Plant-based meat has been gaining popularity worldwide as a more sustainable and ethical alternative to traditional meat. With the rise of veganism and environmental awareness, many people have been turning to plant-based options to reduce their carbon footprint and contribute to a more sustainable food system.

However, despite its global popularity, plant-based meat has yet to capture the Chinese market. This is particularly noteworthy given that China has the largest population in the world, and therefore represents a significant potential market for plant-based meat.

While there has been some growth in the plant-based meat industry in China and Taiwan, it has been slow in comparison to other regions. This can be attributed to a variety of cultural and historical factors that influence Chinese attitudes towards food and meat consumption.

As an ex-vegetarian for over 15 years lived in Asia, I have had the opportunity to observe and experience the cultural attitudes towards meat and plant-based alternatives. Despite my own vegetarian diet, I have noticed the strong cultural attachment to meat in Chinese cuisine and the widespread belief in its health benefits.

However, my personal experience with being vegetarian has also been shaped by my recent move to Germany. While there are a wide variety of plant-based meat options available on the market, I have found that many of them do not meet my expectations in terms of taste and texture.

This personal experience highlights the complexity of the plant-based meat market and the importance of understanding cultural and individual preferences when developing and marketing plant-based alternatives. It also emphasizes the need for further research and innovation in this field to create products that can truly appeal to a diverse range of consumers, including those with strong cultural and culinary traditions surrounding meat consumption.

Historical and Cultural Factors

Overview of Chinese culinary history and traditional diets

To understand why plant-based meat has failed to impress the Chinese, we must first look at the history of Chinese culinary traditions and diets. Meat has been a central component of Chinese cuisine for thousands of years, and it is deeply ingrained in Chinese culture.

According to a study published in the Journal of Ethnic Foods, meat consumption in China has been steadily increasing over the past few decades, with the average meat intake per capita doubling from 28kg in 1992 to 63kg in 2012. This trend is consistent with the growing affluence and prosperity of Chinese society.

The importance of meat in Chinese cuisine can be seen in popular dishes such as Peking duck, hot pot, and braised pork belly. Meat is often used as a flavoring agent, and even dishes that are primarily vegetable-based often include small amounts of meat or meat broth.

The Role of Meat in Traditional Chinese Medicine and Beliefs About its Health Benefits

In addition to its cultural importance, meat also plays a significant role in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). In TCM, different types of meat are believed to have different healing properties and health benefits. For example, pork is believed to strengthen the spleen and stomach, while beef is believed to nourish the blood and promote circulation.

These beliefs about the health benefits of meat are deeply ingrained in Chinese culture, and they have contributed to the widespread consumption of meat in Chinese diets. According to a survey conducted by Ipsos, 62% of Chinese consumers believe that meat is necessary for a healthy diet, compared to just 39% of consumers in the United States.

Comparison to Western Culture and its Dietary Preferences

The cultural differences between China and the West also play a role in the slow growth of plant-based meat in the Chinese market. In Western cultures, there has been a growing awareness of the environmental and ethical issues associated with meat consumption, and this has led to an increase in the popularity of plant-based options.

In contrast, Chinese culture places a greater emphasis on the taste and nutritional value of food, rather than its environmental or ethical impact. For example, in a survey conducted by the Good Food Institute, only 4% of Chinese consumers cited animal welfare as a reason for reducing their meat consumption, compared to 42% of American consumers.

Perception of Vegetarianism in China

How vegetarianism is perceived in China

Vegetarianism has a long history in China, with the concept of a meat-free diet dating back to ancient times. However, despite this history, vegetarianism is not widely practiced in modern China, and many people are reluctant to give up meat.

One reason for this reluctance is the perception of vegetarianism in Chinese culture. According to a survey conducted by Ipsos, 78% of Chinese consumers view vegetarianism as a lifestyle choice rather than a dietary requirement, and only 22% of respondents believed that vegetarianism was necessary for ethical or religious reasons.

Furthermore, vegetarianism is often seen as a Western concept that is not well-suited to Chinese culture and cuisine. In traditional Chinese culture, meat is seen as a symbol of wealth and status, and many Chinese dishes are centered around meat and animal products.

The Chinese plant-based dishes in history

In Chinese cuisine, there are a variety of plant-based dishes that have been developed over the centuries to imitate the taste and texture of meat. These dishes often use ingredients such as mushrooms, soy, wheat gluten, and tofu to create meat-like textures and flavors. Here are a few examples:

1. Braised Wheat Gluten (素烤麸)

Also known as “vegetarian barbecue pork,” braised wheat gluten is a traditional Chinese dish that imitates the flavor and texture of pork. It is made by braising wheat gluten in a sauce made from soy sauce, sugar, and spices, and is often served as a filling for buns or as a topping for rice.

2. Vegetarian “Chicken” (素鸡)

Vegetarian “chicken” is a popular dish in Chinese vegetarian cuisine that is made from soy protein or wheat gluten. It is often seasoned with spices and herbs to imitate the flavor of chicken and can be used in a variety of dishes, including stir-fries, stews, and soups.

3. Buddha’s Delight (罗汉斋)

Buddha’s Delight is a vegetarian dish that originated in China and is often served during Buddhist festivals and other religious ceremonies. It typically contains a variety of vegetables, mushrooms, and tofu, as well as other plant-based ingredients such as bamboo shoots and bean sprouts.

4. Spicy “Beef” (麻辣素牛肉)

Spicy “beef” is a dish that imitates the taste and texture of beef, but is made entirely from plant-based ingredients such as soy protein or mushrooms. It is often served in a spicy sauce made from chili peppers, Sichuan peppercorns, and other spices.

These plant-based dishes have a long history in Chinese cuisine and demonstrate the ingenuity of Chinese cooks in creating meat-like flavors and textures using plant-based ingredients. They also serve as a reminder that vegetarianism and plant-based diets have been a part of Chinese culture for centuries.

Why many Chinese people are reluctant to give up meat

There are several reasons why many Chinese people are reluctant to give up meat. One of the primary reasons is the perceived importance of meat in Chinese diets. As mentioned earlier, meat is seen as a symbol of wealth and status, and it is often used to flavor and enhance the taste of dishes.

In addition to this cultural significance, meat is also viewed as a source of protein and other essential nutrients. According to a study published in the Journal of Ethnic Foods, meat consumption is often seen as a way to ensure adequate nutrition and maintain good health in China.

Another reason why many Chinese people are reluctant to give up meat is the fear of social exclusion. In Chinese culture, food plays an important role in social gatherings and events, and refusing to eat meat may be seen as a sign of disrespect or rudeness.

The cultural significance of meat and how it affects attitudes towards plant-based meat

The cultural significance of meat in Chinese cuisine and society also affects attitudes towards plant-based meat. While plant-based meat may be seen as a healthier and more sustainable alternative to traditional meat, it lacks the cultural and historical significance that meat holds in Chinese culture.

Furthermore, plant-based meat may not be able to replicate the taste and texture of traditional meat dishes, which may limit its appeal to Chinese consumers. In a survey conducted by the Good Food Institute, taste was cited as the most important factor influencing Chinese consumers’ food choices, with 92% of respondents reporting that taste was a “very important” or “important” factor.

Market Analysis

Overview of the current state of the plant-based meat market in China

The current state of the plant-based meat market in China is still in its early stages, but it is growing rapidly. According to a report by research firm Euromonitor, sales of plant-based meat products in China are expected to reach $12 billion by 2023, up from $9.7 billion in 2018.

However, compared to other markets, such as the United States and Europe, the plant-based meat market in China is still relatively small. In the United States, for example, the plant-based meat market was valued at $801 million in 2020, while in Europe it was valued at $1.5 billion.

One of the challenges facing plant-based meat companies in China is competition from traditional meat products. As mentioned earlier, meat is deeply ingrained in Chinese culture and cuisine, and many consumers are reluctant to give up meat in favor of plant-based alternatives.

Another challenge facing plant-based meat companies in China is a lack of understanding of the concept. According to a survey conducted by Ipsos, only 35% of Chinese consumers were familiar with the term “plant-based,” compared to 64% in the United States.

Challenges Facing Plant-Based Meat Companies in China

In addition to competition from traditional meat products and lack of understanding of the concept, there are several other challenges facing plant-based meat companies in China. One of these challenges is the limited availability of plant-based meat products in retail and foodservice outlets.

While plant-based meat products are becoming increasingly popular in China, they are still not widely available in many parts of the country. This limits the potential market for plant-based meat companies and makes it more difficult for them to reach consumers.

Another challenge facing plant-based meat companies in China is regulatory barriers. China has strict regulations on imported food products, and plant-based meat companies may face challenges in obtaining the necessary approvals to sell their products in the country.

Case Studies

There have been several plant-based meat companies that have attempted to enter the Chinese market, including Impossible Foods, Beyond Meat, and Omnipork. While each company has had varying levels of success, all have faced significant challenges in penetrating the Chinese market.

Impossible Foods, for example, initially launched in Hong Kong in 2018, but it took two years for the company to gain approval to sell its products in mainland China. Even then, the company faced regulatory hurdles and had to navigate complex supply chain issues in order to distribute its products.

Beyond Meat also faced challenges when it attempted to enter the Chinese market. While the company partnered with several major foodservice outlets in China, including Starbucks and KFC, it struggled to gain traction with consumers due to the high price of its products and a lack of familiarity with the concept of plant-based meat.

Omnipork, a plant-based pork substitute developed by Hong Kong-based company Right Treat, has had more success in penetrating the Chinese market. The product has been available in retail and foodservice outlets across China since 2018 and has gained popularity due to its taste and affordability.

Sources

1. “Chinese Cuisine and Dietary Culture,” by Hong Zhu, Journal of Ethnic Foods (2016).
2. “Consumer Perceptions and Attitudes towards Plant-Based Meat Substitutes in China,” by Lingyun Yuan et al., Sustainability (2021).
3. “Plant-Based Meat: An Emerging Industry in China,” by Emma Cosgrove, The Spoon (2020).
4. “Plant-Based Meat in China: Challenges and Opportunities,” by Maxime Pourrat, Food and Beverage News (2020).
5. “Why Plant-Based Meat Hasn’t Caught on in China,” by Echo Huang, The Diplomat (2020).

These sources provide insights and data on the current state of the plant-based meat market in China, as well as the cultural and logistical challenges facing companies seeking to enter the market.

If you enjoyed this blog and want to hear more hilarious takes on the latest trends, then follow and subscribe to me on Medium. I promise to keep you entertained with my witty banter and insightful musings.

But don’t stop there! Share this blog with your friends and family. And if you’re feeling extra generous, buy me a coffee to keep my creative juices flowing.

https://www.buymeacoffee.com/YTC9

And last but not least, don’t forget to leave a comment below with your thoughts and opinions. I love hearing from my readers, even if you’re just here to tell me that my writings are terrible.

Thanks for reading, and I’ll catch you on the flip side!